Cottage Cheese Ice Cream (Maple Creemee Style)

JUMP TO RECIPE PIN RECIPE

If you’re obsessed with soft-serve ice cream and love the rich flavor of maple, you need to try this Cottage Cheese Maple Ice Cream. It truly tastes just like a classic Vermont maple creemee, but with far less sugar and calories, more protein, and made with just three simple ingredients. Only 100 calories with 7g protein per serving, refined sugar-free, and shockingly creamy thanks to the cottage cheese base. And no, you can’t taste the cottage cheese at all!

Want to save this recipe?

I'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later! -Sarah

This 3 ingredient cottage cheese ice cream has quickly become one of my go-to Ninja CREAMi recipes. It’s so easy to make and has the dreamiest texture that feels just like a real maple creemee.

Table of Contents

Why This Cottage Cheese Ice Cream Recipe is the Best

1. Soft-Serve Texture Straight from the Ninja CREAMi

This cottage cheese ice cream recipe creates an unbelievably creamy soft-serve texture without any gums, stabilizers, or churners. It’s super smooth and scoopable—no icy bits or weird texture.

2. Only 3 Simple Ingredients

With just cottage cheese, maple syrup, and milk (or cream), it’s quick to prep and easy to customize. Plus, no bananas, protein powder, or complicated add-ins required.

3. Tastes Just Like a Maple Creemee

If you’ve ever had a maple creemee in New England, you know how good they are. This maple creemee recipe tastes just like it, with a protein-packed twist.

3 Ingredient Breakdown

Cottage Cheese

This is the base of the recipe and gives the ice cream a delicious creamy texture. It may sound unusual, but when blended, cottage cheese becomes incredibly smooth and rich and has a very mild flavor. I recommend using a full-fat version for best results, but low fat can be substituted.

Pure Maple Syrup

Pure maple syrup brings that signature maple creemee flavor. It sweetens the ice cream naturally while adding depth and warmth you won’t get from other sweeteners. You can adjust the amount based on desired sweetness and strength of maple flavor, as I find that different maple syrups can have different amounts of sweetness and flavor. I use a Grade B dark amber maple syrup for the most robust maple flavor. For a more delicate maple flavor, use Grade A light amber syrup. You may be able to use sugar free syrup, but I have not tested it yet.

Milk or Cream of Choice

This helps thin the mixture just enough so it blends smoothly and freezes properly. I usually use half and half or whole milk, but feel free to use your favorite milk, cream, or non-dairy milk option of choice.

cottage cheese ice cream maple creemee flavor

How to Make Cottage Cheese Ice Cream

Step 1: Blend the Ingredients

Add the cottage cheese, maple syrup, and milk or cream to a high-speed blender. Blend until completely smooth and creamy with no lumps remaining. It should look like a rich, maple-flavored custard. Taste, and add additional maple syrup if desired.

Step 2: Pour Into Ninja CREAMi Container

Transfer the blended mixture into your Ninja CREAMi pint container. Be sure not to overfill—leave some space at the top.

Step 3: Freeze for 24 Hours

Place the lid on the container and freeze it on a flat surface for at least 24 hours. This step is key for the Ninja CREAMi to process the ice cream properly.

Step 4: Spin Using the Lite Ice Cream Function

Once fully frozen, insert the pint into your Ninja CREAMi machine and spin it on the Lite Ice Cream setting. After the first spin, check the texture—if it looks crumbly, add a splash of milk or cream and respin.

Step 5: Serve and Enjoy

Scoop into a bowl or cone and enjoy immediately. The result is rich, soft-serve style cottage cheese ice cream that’s full of maple creemee flavor.

Tips for Success

Use Full-Fat Cottage Cheese – Low-fat versions can get icy. Full-fat cottage cheese gives the creamiest texture.
Blend Until Completely Smooth – Take your time blending to make sure there are no curds or chunks left behind.
Don’t Skip the Freeze Time – Freezing the mixture for a full 24 hours ensures the Ninja CREAMi can turn it into real ice cream.

Cottage Cheese Ice Cream Maple Flavor Variations

Chocolate Chip Maple

Add mini chocolate chips or chop up a chocolate bar and fold in after the first spin.

Maple Walnut

Stir in a handful of chopped walnuts after spinning for a maple walnut twist.

Maple Chai

Blend in a pinch of cinnamon, cardamom, and a tiny bit of ground ginger to give it a warm chai flavor profile.

FAQs

Can I make cottage cheese ice cream without a Ninja CREAMi?

I recommend using the Ninja or another ice cream maker for best results. If you don’t have an ice cream maker, pour the blended mixture into an ice cube tray and freeze for 3–4 hours. Let it sit at room temp for 10–15 minutes, then re-blend in a high-speed blender or food processor until smooth and creamy. Enjoy right away as soft serve, or refreeze for a firmer version.

Does it taste like cottage cheese?

Not at all. Once blended and frozen, the cottage cheese flavor completely disappears, leaving you with a creamy, rich ice cream.

Is this cottage cheese ice cream recipe keto-friendly?

It’s lower in carbs than traditional ice cream but not technically keto since it uses pure maple syrup. You could experiment with sugar-free maple syrup, but I haven’t tested it yet!

Can I double the recipe?

Yes! Just use two pint containers, and make sure each pint container isn’t filled beyond the “max fill” line.

Try This Cottage Cheese Ice Cream Recipe!

If you’re curious about how to make cottage cheese ice cream that tastes like a creamy, nostalgic maple creemee, this is the one to try. It’s shockingly good for being so simple, and it’s quickly become a favorite in my freezer. I’m excited to continue creating more ice cream recipes, so let me know if you have any flavor requests!

If you make this recipe, I’d love to know what you think. Please leave a comment and star rating below, and tag me on Instagram if you post a photo!

XO,

Sarah